TelecomTV TelecomTV
  • News
  • Videos
  • Channels
  • Events
  • Directory
  • Smart Studio
  • Surveys
  • Debates
  • Perspectives
  • DSP Leaders World Forum
  • DSP Summits
  • Great Telco Debate
    • |
    • Follow
    • |
    • Subscribe
  • |
  • More
  • Webcasts
  • Surveys
  • Debates
  • Perspectives
  • Great Telco Debate
  • |
  • Follow TelecomTV
  • |
    • Subscribe
    • |
  • About
  • Privacy
  • Help
  • Contact
  • Follow TelecomTV
  • About
  • Privacy
  • Help
  • Contact
  • Sign In Register Subscribe
    • Subscribe
    • Sign In
    • Register
  • Search

Net Neutrality

Net Neutrality

US Net Neutrality in the balance

Ian Scales
By Ian Scales

Nov 30, 2015

via Flickr © DonkeyHotey (CC BY 2.0)

via Flickr © DonkeyHotey (CC BY 2.0)

  • Net Neutrality rises again as a US issue
  • Appeals court to rule
  • Judgement may come this Friday (but probably later) 

It’s a testament to just how much political and media power big corporations hold in the US that net neutrality is (seriously!) back in the spotlight. Just when you thought it was all signed, sealed and delivered there is about to be another court challenge to the FCC’s rulemaking on this issue and the right-wing mood music is going up-tempo to convince the public and anyone else that will listen, that this challenge will finally do the trick and overturn the FCC's reclassification of broadband services as ‘common carrier’.

But opinions on this are sharply divided, of course.

The story so far (brief version for boredom avoidance): Obama came to office (first term) apparently ready to take on the telcos and instigate some sort of Internet Neutrality. He installed his Democrat FCC Chairman in 2009, as is his right, and tasked Julius Genachowski to gather information and come up with a cunning plan. Time elapsed and not much seemed to happen, then eventually in 2010 came the Open Internet Order, some light regulation mandating ISPs not to block websites and be discriminatory. There was grumbling but overall the impression was that ISPs (especially wireless providers) had been let off lightly. Then came the Verizon-led court challenge that overturned the FCC order on a technicality. It was a temporary no to net neutrality.

Eventually, after much lobbying and counter-lobbying, public pressure, and the intervention of a British TV comedian, Obama reclassified the ISP business as ‘Title 2’ (subject to regulation as a common carrier), introduced net neutrality rules, another court case was launched and here we are in late 2015 on the verge of hearing its opinion.

The line from big telco, big cable and the Republicans in Congress is that the FCC still lacks the legal basis to impose the net neutrality rules, and a panel of judges, chosen randomly to avoid bias, will decide who is right.  

Crunch time is this Friday when that panel, convened as the U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia, will be listening to arguments. But the twist in this tale is that the panel includes one Judge David Tatel. Tatel was instrumental in the striking down of net neutrality twice before so the anti-neutrals think that, given that history, he’s most likely influence his fellow judges to block again. The FCC and its supporters have a different take.

They point to the fact that Tatel emphasised in the last judgement that his ruling was nothing to do with the ins and outs of net neutrality itself, but rather on the narrow legalistic point that the FCC had not granted itself the authority to make the change. In other words, if the FCC wanted to institute regulatory powers, they would have to reclassify first.

On that basis the FCC thinks Tatel will give it the all-clear, since the current chairman, Tom Wheeler, effectively did what Tatel said and reclassified.

It’s rather difficult to tell what the outcome is going to be since there is a confident clamour from both sides - we’ll report back as soon as we know.

Related Topics
  • Analysis & Opinion,
  • Net Neutrality,
  • News,
  • Policy & Regulation

More Like This

Policy & Regulation

Sufferin' Succotash! Tweety Pai says goodbye

Jan 21, 2021

Broadband

Democrats pass infrastructure bill designed to expand broadband access

Jul 2, 2020

Net Neutrality

Will 2020 see a state-by-state return to net neutrality in the US?

Dec 20, 2019

Data & Analytics

Personalization is on the slide as consumers refuse to share data

Dec 3, 2019

Broadband

Brits keen to help build community-owned broadband networks, but pay for them? Not so much

Jul 15, 2019

Email Newsletters

Stay up to date with the latest industry developments: sign up to receive TelecomTV's top news and videos plus exclusive subscriber-only content direct to your inbox – including our daily news briefing and weekly wrap.

Subscribe

Top Picks

Highlights of our content from across TelecomTV today

DSP Leaders World Forum 2021 Delegate Report

0:50

DSP Leaders Open Telco Summit

23:25

Extra Shot: Next Steps for DSPs

11:17

How cloud dynamics are reshaping the telecoms sector

  • TelecomTV
  • Decisive Media

TelecomTV is produced by the team at Decisive Media

Menu
  • News
  • Videos
  • Channels
  • Directory
  • Smart Studio
 
  • Surveys
  • Debates
  • Perspectives
  • Events
  • About Us
Our Brands
  • TelecomTV Tracker
  • TelecomTV Perspectives
  • DSP Summits
  • DSP Leaders World Forum
  • The Great Telco Debate
Get In Touch
info@telecomtv.com
+44 (0) 207 448 1070

Request a Media Pack

Follow
  • © Decisive Media Limited 2021. All rights reserved. All brands and products are the trademarks of their respective holder(s).
  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • Legal Notices