TelecomTV
  • News
  • Videos
  • Channels
  • Events
  • Directory
  • Webcasts
  • Surveys
  • Debates
  • Perspectives
  • More
  • Directory
  • Webcasts
  • Surveys
  • Debates
  • Perspectives
  • Follow TelecomTV
  • About
  • Help
  • Contact
  • Follow TelecomTV
  • About
  • Help
  • Contact
  • Sign In Register Subscribe
    • Subscribe
    • Sign In
    • Register
  • Search

Net Neutrality

Net Neutrality

Is the Internet an inherently interstate service?

Ian Scales
By Ian Scales

Oct 4, 2018

via Flickr © credo.action (CC BY 2.0)

via Flickr © credo.action (CC BY 2.0)

  • Pai says it is.
  • No it’s not. Neutrality is only expected in the access network
  • And... where you can implement non neutral services for individuals and their connections, you can also turn them off!

Since Monday and the passing of the Californian neutrality law, the US ISPs have predictably launched a counter-attack. Comcast, Verizon, Cox Communications, AT&T along with the NCTA, USTelecom, the American Cable Association, and the CTIA have all piled in to file a lawsuit in the US District Court for the Eastern District of California to get the new law overturned.

New facts and allegations are being brought into the conversation. Most notably - as Ajit Pai told reporters in Washington - that the internet is “inherently an interstate service... From a legal perspective we’re on very strong ground,” he claimed. And further that because of this it would be impossible to operate with different regulations in different states.

There’s quite a few problems with this line of attack. There’s the obvious one: that in abrogating authority over ISPs, the FCC had left a legal vacuum which, common sense would indicate, could and should be filled by state authorities. Since the FCC had no interest in protecting citizens’ rights then states had, reluctantly, to take up the challenge.

But I think there’s an even better pushback against all this  because of a very obvious contradiction. Pai’s assertion that the interstate nature of the Internet rules out local legislation sort of works as a legal abstraction, but in reality it is dead wrong.  

Simply put, if you have the technology available to introduce and manage discriminatory, non-neutral services, then that same technology can be used to turn them off just as selectively and just as automatically, depending on a user’s location. How could it be otherwise?

Take personalisation - one of the big ‘wouldn’t it be nice’ wet dreams harboured by ISPs is the notion that you could personalise the Internet and get users to pay independently for the sites they wanted to access -  2 dollars for this, 5 dollars for that, and so on. The defining details for that would reside in the user’s profile which is constructed when his or her service is ordered and fulfilled by the OSS/BSS system.

Another is to offer better than ‘best effort’ data performance, perhaps on an ad hoc basis, when users are experiencing difficulty and seeing whirling wheels on their screens (seriously - that was a thing!).

The point is, that to make any of this ISP behaviour real you have to have individual user profiles which cause the system to bill (say) in one way for one customer, in a different way for the next. They have to operate on the system in real time.

So where an ISP is servicing a customer on the California side of the state line, his/her service profile goes neutral while those on the other side of line get whatever the ISP sees fit.

Related Topics
  • 4G LTE,
  • 5G,
  • Analysis & Opinion,
  • AT&T,
  • Broadband,
  • Comcast,
  • FCC,
  • Net Neutrality,
  • News,
  • North America,
  • Telco & CSP,
  • Verizon

More Like This

Net Neutrality

Zero rating video content has adverse effects, claims study

Feb 8, 2019

Net Neutrality

Has weed whacker Ajit Pai been caught out?

Feb 5, 2019

Broadband

Broadband Forum Gfast solutions certifications jump to more than 40 as deployment success stories proliferate

Feb 1, 2019

Net Neutrality

AT&T warms up for the non-neutrality game

Jan 4, 2019

Net Neutrality

Is Porkies Pai planning an 'alternative numbers' factory?

Dec 13, 2018

Email Newsletters

Stay up to date with the latest industry developments: sign up to receive TelecomTV's top news and videos plus exclusive subscriber-only content direct to your inbox – including our daily news briefing and weekly wrap.

Subscribe

Top Picks

Highlights of our content from across TelecomTV today

Debate 4: Analytics, Machine Learning and the Edge

1:06

Guide to TIP: Edge Computing

5:09

Lumina Networks: Tying the old to the new with SDN

3:15

The Route from CSP to DSP is Open

  • TelecomTV
  • Decisive Media

TelecomTV is produced by the team at Decisive Media

Menu
  • News
  • Videos
  • Channels
  • Directory
  • Webcasts
 
  • Surveys
  • Debates
  • Perspectives
  • Events
  • About Us
Our Brands
  • TelecomTV Tracker
  • TelecomTV Perspectives
  • DSP Leaders Forum
  • Open Service Provider
  • The Great Telco Debate
Get In Touch
info@telecomtv.com
+44 (0) 207 448 1070

Request a Media Pack

Follow
  • © Decisive Media Limited 2019. All rights reserved. All brands and products are the trademarks of their respective holder(s).
  • Legal Notices