Connect
Related Content
Green Planet
Green Planet
What impact does ICT have on greenhouse gas emissions, energy use and the environment?
And what role can ICT play in helping alleviate the problems in other business areas?
TelecomTV One - News
The lawyers pile in
 
Bookmark and Share

Comcast still smarting over 'throttling' episode: comes out fighting

Posted By TelecomTV One , 14 August 2009 | 1 Comments | (1)
Tags: Comcast FCC net neutrality Internet

The FCC under chairman Julius Genachowski has yet to take up the firm Internet neutrality positions trailed before his appointment. Now the latest move by Comcast and its supporters to appeal the famous throttling censure delivered by the FCC last year, could make an enforceable policy (if it eventuates) even more difficult to engineer. By Ian Scales.

US cable company, Comcast, says it's going to appeal the Federal Communications Commission (FCC)'s order to halt "discriminatory network management practices", delivered against Comcast following the well-publicised fracas over Comcast's practise of "throttling" P2P Internet traffic (see - Throttling the Net American Style: Regulator chokes Comcast)

The trouble began back in 2007 when Comcast was caught "managing" BitTorrent traffic by forging packets to throttle torrents when the load became too great on the Comcast network.

The P2P BitTorrent file transfers overcome the asymmetric characteristics of both DSL and cable modem networks by simultaneously uploading separate segments of identical files (music or movie files, usually) hosted on end-user PCs. The multiple file technique avoids what would otherwise be an impossibly slow transfer time, but too much of this traffic causes congestion on the back-haul networks, claim ISPs, hence the need to throttle it at busy times. Standoff.

In the end Comcast admitted it was wrong and amended its management practises so that they were 'protocol agnostic'.


» This story continues on page 2. Please click here to read
Advertisement
please sign in to rate this article
45375
 

1 comments (Add Yours) - click here to sign in

(1) 18 August 2009 18:24:08 by Francis McInerney

The problem for Comcast is that it has no model for monetizing the backhaul and therefore cannot justify customer-to-customer high bandwidth communications.

At the Corporate Innovation Project in New York, we have a solution to the backhaul problem that is elegant, simple, and will throw off a lot of cash. Using it, Comcast can monetize its backhaul and, in doing so, will find that it must encourage maximum C-to-C communication with the most powerful cameras and other gear available.

Bandwidth throttling and the customer alienation it engenders will vanish in a trice. Indeed,the money is so big in our solution that Comcast will be at the FCC begging it to insist on an end to throttling.

But, and it''s a big but, the CIP solution, while simple, means throwing out Comcast''s dreams of content aggregation. Indeed, our simple path to backhaul monetization eliminates all network TV, rating agencies, and CPM-based advertising. They are the horse and buggy of next gen TV.

As it is, Comcast''s structure makes it look like a newspaper in search of a Craig''s List to inhale all of its cash flow.

Reversing this structure to put our solution in place will be an OFCF engine for sure, slash days to cash, and put Comcast on the brand high ground. But a lot of folks there will not make the transition. Sic transit ...